Important Disclaimer
The information provided here is for general pet health education only and is not a substitute for professional veterinary advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Never disregard professional veterinary advice or delay seeking it because of something you read here. If your pet is experiencing a medical emergency, contact your veterinarian or an emergency animal hospital immediately.
- Species & breed
- Dog · Mixed Breed
- Age
- 5 months old
- Sex
- Female
- Color
- Black
It's great that you're thinking carefully about Storm's nutrition at such an important stage in her life — the first year really does set the foundation for a dog's long-term health.
The honest answer is: both approaches can work, and both have real trade-offs. Here's a general overview to help you think it through.
Commercial kibble (the dry bagged food most people use) has a few practical advantages:
- It's formulated to meet established nutritional standards, so a quality kibble should contain the right balance of protein, fat, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals.
- It's convenient and shelf-stable.
- Puppy-specific formulas are designed to support growth, which matters a lot for a 5-month-old.
The key word is quality — not all kibble is equal, and ingredients and sourcing vary widely between brands.
Whole foods like boiled chicken and rice are gentle, digestible, and easy for dogs to tolerate — which is why vets often recommend them short-term when a dog has an upset stomach. However, as a long-term main diet, plain chicken and rice is generally considered nutritionally incomplete. Dogs need a wide range of nutrients (calcium, phosphorus, essential fatty acids, and more) that a simple two-ingredient meal doesn't provide on its own.
Home-cooked or "fresh food" diets can absolutely be healthy, but they take real effort to balance correctly. Many pet owners who go this route work with a veterinary nutritionist to make sure the recipes cover everything their dog needs — especially for a growing puppy.
A few things worth knowing for a 5-month-old mixed breed like Storm:
- Puppies have higher energy and nutrient needs than adult dogs, so getting the balance right is especially important right now.
- Whatever diet you choose, look for something that meets AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) standards for "growth" or "all life stages" — that label means it's been formulated or tested for puppies.
When to see your vet: This is a great topic to bring up at Storm's next puppy wellness visit — ideally soon, since she's at an age where nutrition really matters. If you're considering switching from kibble to a home-cooked or fresh diet, ask your vet for a referral to a board-certified veterinary nutritionist who can help you build a complete and balanced plan. Also reach out promptly if Storm shows any signs of poor growth, low energy, dull coat, or digestive issues, as these can sometimes signal a nutritional gap.
Was this answer helpful?
Your feedback helps us improve answers for every pet.